Why transnational lists are neither European nor democratic

07.02.2018 - 10:05
European Parliament

The idea that MEPs are more European, and would therefore better safeguard Europe and European ideas, if they are disconnected from their electorates is absurd and based on an artificial view of what being European is and on what democracy is.

Closing the gap

Europe is not the people we meet in the European Parliament or in the European Commission. Europe is the people of Helsinki and Malmö, of Valencia and Valetta, students and researchers in all of our universities, people who go to work in factories and shops and hospitals. Young, old, women and men.

The idea of transnational lists, where MEPs are elected without constituencies and without responsibility, rejects this true Europe. Therefore, the transnational lists should be rejected.

At a time when people are experiencing a confidence gap between voters and political representatives it would be a mistake to widen the gap even further.

Removing the electoral constituencies in favour of European political groups would weaken the link between Members and their electorate. Consequently, the European Parliament would get MEPs without local support.

This creates a more distant and centralised European Union, rather than a more democratic and accountable one.

Countering populism - the need for clear responsibility

Transnational lists would strengthen the populists and the counterparts of Farage, Le Pen and Wilders. Those who are against the very idea of the European Union but who have no intention of discussing the challenges we face and taking responsibility.

They are the ones who benefit from the lack of scrutiny from a defined electorate. The losers would be the citizens of Europe.

A European constituency with accountability to no one would make the EU a project for the elites instead of a Union rooted in the realities of our citizens.

Keeping the diversity in 'United in diversity'

The success of the European Union stems from the combination of visionary idealism with realistic pragmatism. Our common challenges need to be met with a united response, but the idea that more centralisation equals more Europe is misguided.

European citizens benefit from EU legislation through trade, freedom of movement, a common telecoms market and increased cooperation on foreign and security policy, but Europe goes beyond the institutions in Brussels and Strasbourg. Europe is its countries, regions, villages and citizens.

The words “united in diversity” are not only about unity but also about diversity. You cannot have one without the other.

The dynamism and strength of Europe come from balancing national and European interests, small and big countries, different EU institutions, political parties and regions.

As citizens, we elect our representatives. Our representatives must be connected with their electorate. That’s democracy and that's how Europe can be strong, united and a vision coming true step-by-step, defined by us all together as citizens.


EIN Riga
22.05.2018 - 09:24

Lech Wałęsa to receive merit award from EIN in Riga

The annual gathering of the European Ideas Network (EIN) will take place in Riga, Latvia, from 23 to 25 May with European politicians, academics,...
Nicole Fontaine EP President at a plenary session in Strasbourg on July 1999
18.05.2018 - 21:19

Passing of N.Fontaine: a militant of the European ideal

“It is with a deep sadness that I learnt of the passing of Nicole Fontaine. After Simone Veil, the first woman elected as President of the...
traffic on german autobahn,european cars and trucks
17.05.2018 - 13:22

EPP Group in favour of capping CO2 emissions for trucks

EPP Group backs Commission’s proposal to cut CO2 emissions for trucks, but urges that we remain realistic The EPP Group in the European...
Environment Committee backs stronger EU disaster relief
17.05.2018 - 12:00

Environment Committee backs stronger EU disaster relief

The European Parliament’s Environment Committee has approved draft legislation to step up EU disaster relief. Authored by the EPP Group’s...

Highlights of the week

22.05.2018 - 25.05.2018
Riga, Latvia

Discussing the European way of life in Riga

European politicians, academics, policy-makers and opinion-shapers will gather in Riga, Latvia, from 23-25 May at the annual conference of the...

Mark Zuckerberg to meet EP leaders

An extraordinary meeting with the Chief Executive Officer of Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg, will take place on Tuesday in the European Parliament. The...
High angle view of traffic on highway

Road charges: fair charging for better roads

The Transport and Tourism Committee will vote on Thursday morning on the phasing-out of the Eurovignette for heavy duty vehicles and vans....